Product review

The Best Baking Sheets: A Buyer’s Guide

Looking for the best baking sheets? These baking sheet reviews break down features, materials and pros and cons of three great options.

To Review
best baking sheet

Whether I'm baking up batches of cookies or crafting tasty sheet pan dinners with a variety of veggies, baking sheets are definitely a kitchen essential. But not all baking sheets are created equal. The best baking sheet will provide even heat distribution for perfect texture and flavor, and have a high-quality, durable construction that will stand the test of time and high temperatures of your oven. To help you pick the perfect addition to your kitchen toolkit, I've compiled details on three fantastic options, complete with their pros and cons.

budget sheet baking review
Budget Choice

Nordic Ware Baker's Half Sheet

Nordic Ware's budget-friendly baking sheet boasts a professional design with its pure, uncoated aluminum, user-friendly compatibility and natural non-stick surface.

Material: Aluminum 

Size: Half Sheet, 2-Pack

This budget-friendly baking sheet is made with pure, uncoated natural aluminum. It works well with parchment paper or silicone baking mats, making it super easy to use, and even easier to clean! The encapsulated solid core steel rim makes the design extra durable, and the non-porous, aluminum surface ensures nothing sticks, without any chemical coatings, while also offering great heat conductivity. This is one of the most professional designs that you will find at this price point.


  • Made of pure, uncoated, natural aluminum
  • Compatible with parchment paper or silicone baking mats
  • Encapsulated solid core steel rim


  • Shiny and non-porous natural aluminum provides natural nonstick performance
  • Superior heat conductivity
  • Pure aluminum will never rust


  • Not dishwasher-friendly
  • Metal utensils and scouring pads may scratch natural aluminum pans
  • Aluminum is reactive to acidic ingredients such as vinegar and tomato products. These foods may darken, pit, or corrode the pan after prolonged use
premium baking sheet review
Premium Choice

Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet

The Caraway baking sheet is the premium choice for avid bakers, offering a toxic-free composition, slick non-stick surface and compatibility with various ovens.

Material: Aluminum

Size: 10” X 15” 

Whether you're roasting veggies or baking a batch of cookies, the high-quality Caraway baking sheet is a must-have. Being free from toxic materials like lead, cadmium, and other harmful substances is a significant win for health-conscious bakers. The slick, non-stick feature is a true time-saver, making cleanup super easy. With the ability to handle oven temperatures up to 550ºF, they are compatible with induction, gas, and electric ovens. Plus, you'll appreciate that they require less oil for baking and practically no scrubbing for a spotless finish. 


  • Free from PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, cadmium, and other toxic materials
  • Slick non-stick
  • Can withstand oven temperatures up to 550ºF


  • Compatible with induction, gas, and electric ovens.
  • Requires less oil for baking than other sheets
  • Minimal scrubbing for a spotless clean


  • Not dishwasher friendly
  • A little heavy
  • Not broiler friendly
best baking sheet review
Responsible Choice

GreenLife Bakeware Half Cookie Sheet

The GreenLife baking sheet is a health-conscious choice, with natural non-stick ceramic, heavy-duty steel composition and a company commitment to sustainable practices.

Material: Ceramic, Aluminum, Stainless Steel

Size: Half baking sheet

This is a standout choice for health conscious bakers. Made with a natural ceramic non-stick coating, it's free of PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium. The company’s commitment to sustainability sets it apart from others, with a 60% reduction in CO2 emissions during the nonstick coating process. The nonstick coating is derived from sand, instead of chemicals. It’s oven-safe up to 450°F and designed with heavy-duty steel for quick and even heat distribution.


  • Made with healthy ceramic non-stick free of PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium
  • 60% less CO2 emissions than traditional nonstick in the nonstick coating process.
  • Sand-derived nonstick


  • Oven safe up to 450°F 
  • Crafted from heavy-duty steel for fast and even heat distribution
  • It is super easy to clean


  • It can get scratched
  • Not dishwasher-friendly
  • Not spray oil-friendly

Best Recipes Using Baking Sheets

Best Baking Sheets

I am a big advocate for baking over frying whenever possible, as it allows you to eliminate unnecessary oil in your cooking, and it’s also more efficient, meaning you can set a timer and walk away from the oven while your recipes cook up. The perfect baking sheet will ensure your food doesn’t burn or stick, while cooking it effectively and evenly. Regardless of if you’re on a budget, or looking for an option that aligns with your sustainable values, these are some of the best baking sheets available. Whichever you choose, you'll have a great option that is safe to use and built to last.